galaxyBETA
explore
· ·
log in

log me in

log in forgot password

don't have an account?

sign up

preferences

theme picker site-wide filters

comments for Applemania

sort: go back

DiesWhenKilled August 18, 2024
+22comment score: 22

The progression of this game feels exponentially worse as you play. Every upgrade feels like it gives you a small boost in exchange for a big time wall, and you have to be constantly moving to take full advantage of these small boosts.

I'm currently Level 4 (16 apples per collection), the cheapest upgrade costs 1,951 apples, the most expensive costs 12,500 apples. Unless there is a new feature I'm literally just about to unlock, I fail to see any point in continuing to spend longer and longer holding down different combinations of WASD to chase more of the same four upgrades.

Acod verifier August 18, 2024
+19comment score: 19

1. diagonal movement is faster than moving in one direction, doesn't necessarily have to be fixed
2. the first apple cap upgrade doesn't do anything :( not rounded up?

Neffdigity August 20, 2024
+14comment score: 14

Tristan is 100% correct. This is basically Grass Cutting Incremental but worse, at least in it's current state. I've noticed that certain people here on Galaxy seem to get downvoted for valid opinions they have even when other people have the exact same opinion. It's like people are using the likes/dislikes for personal vendetta and grudges instead of to actually downvoting misinformation and bad faith comments. I've noticed people, like Tristan get like one or two downvotes near consistently no matter what they post here. Seems like somebody maybe purposely following certain people around just to downvote spam someone they didn't like. Kind of reddit like behavior if you ask me. Probably gonna get downvoted to oblivion for pointing this hard truth out, but if this is gonna be the reddit of incremental game sites, where we are gonna brigade, and be forced to either be insulting critical of a game or basically licking the creators boots with no middle ground, then so be it. Downvote me to the shadow realm, you'll only be proving my point.

True_Randomness August 18, 2024
+9comment score: 9

GCI Browser used the mouse for player movement; this would be easier

Termt August 18, 2024
+8comment score: 8

I was a little disappointed that the character didn't wrap around the edges to the other side of the area.

CrownedBird August 23, 2024
+6comment score: 6

The game hasn’t even touched the stove yet, it really needs to be cooked a little more.

laleyou donator August 20, 2024
+4comment score: 4

It's an impressive game, I made it to level 100 actually. Going long with only one resource/mechanic and adding all the detail so subtly, is apparently hard to understand but being done up like this it's very interesting and nice to see for sure.

sese_mueller August 20, 2024
+4comment score: 4

Interesting game, minimalist gameplay. 3/5. I profiled it and the main problem is that there's large GC usage sometimes.

lingluo August 19, 2024
+3comment score: 3

Game looks good but pacing is way too slow and I simply lose patience at around level 6.

tristan countest August 21, 2024
+3comment score: 3

Well, reaching Tier 1 was immeasurably disappointing. Upgrade costs are far more expensive now with no real upgrade, and it feels like I'm back to the beginning of the game, with the only difference being a few more OoMs in the upgrade cost.

sharpnova August 20, 2024
+3comment score: 3

i don't like that you can continue to pay to upgrade the maximum amount of apples, with the cost continuing to increase, even when it's capped. and the cost increases carry over to the next tier. meaning you just make the game exponentially harder for yourself by buying that upgrade once it's capped.

GoldOfRobloxia2 August 18, 2024
+3comment score: 3

make the game bettee on mobile, its playable but not how its supposed to be played

Acod verifier August 19, 2024
+3comment score: 3

imo easy way to make it less painful is to make experience for levels total apples collected instead of the apples you currently have, it almost feels like often some upgrades aren't worth to purchase but if i don't the grind of doing nothing continues

Ivanisdabest14 August 21, 2024
+2comment score: 2

@Acod the first apple cap upgrade actually rounds up, just like that the 3 * 1.25 is 3.75, and the apples only counts of a first digit

ecxo August 22, 2024
+2comment score: 2

Very fun idea, but after tiering up everything seemed to be the same with bigger numbers.

incraldanerd counter August 18, 2024
+2comment score: 2

dude, how did you manage to lock the screen size?

sbloom85 September 11, 2024
+2comment score: 2

You should make the play area smaller so it doesn't need scroll bars to view the entire game.

unicodes gamedev August 21, 2024
+2comment score: 2

needs some early-game automation

Ivanisdabest14 August 20, 2024
+2comment score: 2

Maplefrog7 there is arrow keys nor wasd

alexJ August 19, 2024
+1comment score: 1

great idea terrible execution
as acod mentioned a much better system for levels would be total apples collected instead of the amount you have
spent like 2 hours in total on the original non galaxy upload and the only new content i found was an extra upgrade that didnt seem to do much
a better pacing would make this game x10 better